Matthew Miner's Basic-ish BlogMatthew Miner's Blog

Sometimes I might say something

Cookie Confusion

PRODUCTS LAW

The recent news that Mondelēz International—parent company of Nabisco and producer of Oreos, Chips Ahoy, Nutter Butter, and many other snack goods—is suing Aldi, popular budget-friendly grocery store. This is not for just copying cookies. There's nothing illegal about producing such similar products, or else Nabisco would itself be in trouble for cloning Hydrox. Instead, it is for allegedly infringing Nabisco's products' trade dress.

Trade dress is a sister concept to trade mark which, instead of protecting a name or other mark, protects distinctive packaging. Like trademark, the test for trade dress infringement is likelihood of confusion. If you saw store brand "crème-filled chocolate sandwich cookies" on the shelves, is it likely that you would think them to be genuine Oreos?

Ultimately, this is a question for a jury, but I thought it would be interesting to present the following table of such packagings, along with other major store brands' so you can compare for yourself.

Mondelēz Aldi Walmart Kroger Amazon Dollar General
Nabisco Oreo Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Aldi Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Walmart Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Kroger Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Whole Foods Chocolate Sandwich Cookies Dollar General Chocolate Sandwich Cookies
Nabisco Wheat Thins Aldi Thin Wheat Crackers Walmart Thin Wheat Crackers Kroger Thin Wheat Crackers Whole Foods Thin Wheat Crackers Dollar General Thin Wheat Crackers
Nabisco Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies Aldi Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Walmart Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Kroger Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Amazon Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Dollar General Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
Nabisco Chips Ahoy Chocolate Chip Cookies Aldi Chocolate Chip Cookies Walmart Chocolate Chip Cookies Kroger Chocolate Chip Cookies Amazon Chocolate Chip Cookies Dollar General Chocolate Chip Cookies

Bonus: Hydrox's packaging

The above is my understanding of the law. I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer. This post does not constitute legal advice. I make no warranty as to its accuracy or applicability to you. If you need a lawyer, get a lawyer. If you want me specifically, hire me.

Previous Post